Your guide to better porn!

HomeCategoriesAmateurPeter Girls review - 1st revisit

Peter Girls Review

Summary: Peter Girls is a very high quality amateur site that launched in Sep 2009. The site is quite large and offers hi-res and HD downloads. The models are mix of nubile pornstars and real amateur girls stripping and teasing in very high quality softcore pictorials and movies. Updates are pretty regular and while parts of the site are a bit outdated it still offers a great experience for fans of real amateur girls.

Score 80 /100
About Our Ratings
Jerry Fritz, 2020-07-20

Video count:

Amateur, 18-23, Babes, Handjobs, Hardcore, High-definition, Movies, Photography / studio, Softcore, Videos

first timers, outdoor posing, Peter Romero, solo posing, stripping

Intro promises

"Fresh and real amatuer girls next door!"

- Real American amateur girls
- Exclusive and first-time on camera
- HD Videos and Hi-res pics

First impression

If you want to see real American girls getting naked, nervously showing off their perky tits, and masturbating for the first time ever on camera then it maybe worth your while to check out Peter Girls. This site brings you hundreds of blue blooded girls next door flaunting their bodies, their pussies, and their all natural figures in auditions, galleries, and videos.v


Payment Processors:

Our opinion

You may not know their names, but Peter and Chelsea Romero discovered such All-American porn cuties as Bree Olson. Since 2002 they've been cruising the states in search of new talents, real girl next door beauties who have never posed before. Here on their official site, Peter Girls, they upload all the content they've made on their journey.

For the most part Peter Girls is a softcore site. Just about every update features a cute and somewhat nervous teen amateur posing in her thong or a bikini and undressing, showing off her perky tits and her pink pussy. Typically the nerves wear off in a few minutes and the girls start to feel sexy with the camera watching them. This is typically when they bring out the sex toys and start to masturbate.

The site is pretty big, with 612 total updates posted. These typically involve at least one gallery and video each and sometimes more. They say True HD but the resolutions I found were 1440x1080 (8 mbits). The quality was pretty great but could be better. There were also lower resolution downloads available.

One oddity - there was no embedded player to stream movies in the members area. In 2020, that struck me as really odd. I actually visited this site almost seven years ago and the members area hasn't changed much, though the video downloads have improved in technical quality. To stream the videos you have to click a view text link on the page, which looks a bit old school, but still works fine.

The picture galleries can be viewed in an automated slideshow or saved in a Zip-file download. The slideshow isn't ideal - it just flashes full-sized photos every two seconds, and if you don't have a big monitor you won't see the entire image - so I think you'll have to download the sets of images if you want to enjoy them best.

Peter and Chelsea add new girls to the site every 2-3 days on average. There are 207 total models listed at the time of my visit.

The Live Shows link the members area just logs you out of the members area and the Bonus Sites link lists a few sites none of which you'll have any access to - they're just recommendations, which was disappointing.


Peter Girls remains a great archive of fresh and real amatuer girls but certain aspects of the members area is growing out of date, including the lack of a streaming video player. With a big archive online it's still a nice option for fans of real amateur girls.


Girls Out West is also dedicated to real amateur girls, only these babes aren't from America, they're from Australia. You'll find a mix of artistic and high quality softcore, lesbian, and hardcore content here all starring all natural ladies.

FTV Girls is a bit more polished but its gorgeous babes and club girls are also amateurs and not professional porn stars. They have a huge library and some really high quality content.


Screenshot 1 from members areaScreenshot 2 from members areaScreenshot 3 from members areaScreenshot 4 from members areaScreenshot 5 from members area


Image sample 1 from members areaImage sample 2 from members areaImage sample 3 from members areaImage sample 4 from members areaImage sample 5 from members area

External Opinions

Don't take our word for it and see what others think! We have collected a list of opinions and impressions from other sites, so you can compare them all from one place.

Total average: 82.8/100 Our score: 80/100

User Comments

Write your comment - feedback is appreciated


Comments from other readers

No comments yet - please help make our site better for everyone by adding your comment.