Your guide to better porn!

HomeCategoriesAmateurBoys First Time review

Boys First Time review

Summary: When these guys decide to have their first gay experience, they don't want to do it behind closed doors. They want the world to know what they're doing, so they go ahead and go for it on camera. That's the best idea ever, and Boys First Time captures over 300 of these experiences. With a big collection, a long running site, and frequent updates this one is a real winner.

Score 80.0 /100
About Our Ratings
Tiffany, 2009-10-14


fresh faced gay hotties, gay amateurs, gay first timers

Intro promises

30+ minute episodes
Fresh faced gay amateurs
26 bonus sites
All exclusive

First impression

First times are always so much fun and when you have amateur gay hotties willing to have their first man on man experience on camera well that makes it that much better. Boys First Time is run by Reality Kings, who are quite adept at finding not only hot amateurs, but they also know how to keep the amateur feel going throughout.

Said amateur feel is certainly retained in the member's area design, which goes for short, sweet, and simple. That doesn't mean that they're skimping on functionality, however. The navigation covers all the major sections that you would need for the main collection and the bonus sites, and the rest of the main area is enticing with all sorts of boys enjoying their first taste of cock.


Payment Processors:

Our opinion

Boys First Time caught my interest right at the start, regardless of the fact that there are many gay first time sites out there. Reality Kings prides themselves on producing a quality product, and the fact that they get a very authentic amateur vibe going with their content is another reason for my interest. They don't have a ton of experience in the gay field, with just one other site that I'll talk about in the bonus section, but they do seem to have an eye for picking out the guys.

Most of the men featured on this site are guys next door there's a few straight up twinks, but most of them are of an average build. There are 357 episodes currently on the site, and they tend to add a new first timer every week. They've been at this for quite some time, so you'll see all sorts of sexy amateurs that need their taste of man meat on camera.

The episode pages are separated into pictures, screencaps, and videos. That makes it pretty easy to bounce around to each aspect of the episode. Being the video whore that I am, we'll start there first. The videos are available in WMV for full scene and big clips, while 1 minute clips get the MPG treatment. The best quality is shown at 720x480 and 1.5 mbps, although there is a progression up to this point through the older videos, which tend to be around 352x240 and 500 kbps. They've certainly come a long way, and their dedication to improvement really shows through. The videos run for 20 minutes long, giving you plenty of time to enjoy these succulent twinks.

The picture sets, both photo shoots and screencaps, have over 200 pictures per set. There's a standard gallery setup with zip downloads available, and the photo shoot pictures are shown at 600x900 and very good quality, while the screencaps are 720x480.

Boys First Time also offers two bonus sites Papi and Tranny Surprise. Papi is all about hot gay Latino amateurs who are enjoying the lime light, while Tranny Surprise pops their cocks on unsuspecting guys. They're both well done, although most likely you'll be checking out Papi before venturing over into tranny land.


Boys First Time is a long running gay amateur site that has the legs to go for another eight years. The collection is huge, the updates come like clockwork, and the current video quality is looking rather good. The bonus sites help to add the cherry on top, so stop on by.


Screenshot 1 from members areaScreenshot 2 from members areaScreenshot 3 from members areaScreenshot 4 from members areaScreenshot 5 from members area


Image sample 1 from members areaImage sample 2 from members areaImage sample 3 from members areaImage sample 4 from members areaImage sample 5 from members area

External Opinions

Don't take our word for it and see what others think! We have collected a list of opinions and impressions from other sites, so you can compare them all from one place.

Total average: 83.4/100 Our score: 80.0/100

User Comments

Write your comment - feedback is appreciated


Comments from other readers

No comments yet - please help make our site better for everyone by adding your comment.