Your guide to better porn!


Amateur reviews

Lusting after fresh faced, new to the porn scene gay guys? In our gay amateur category, you'll find the sexiest amateur gay guys who might be a bit shy at first. Before long they're warming up to the camera though, opening up their pants to reveal eager cocks, looking around for another guy to suck off, and spreading their asses open for the ultimate amateur gay pleasure.

Primarily Amateur sites | All Amateur related sites

← Previous Page Next Page →
Total 34 reviews
  • Now: $29.99
    Boy Fun Collection screenshot
    Boy Fun Collection
    Date: 2018-05-05
    Your price: $29.99.

    Summary: There are so many twink and gay amateur sites out there that it makes me want to scream sometimes but Boy Fun Collection makes it all better. This is THE go to site for those gay porn niches, and you are going to have to check it out at least once. They do everything right, the collection is almost all exclusive, and daily updates mean that you will never, ever get bored.

  • Now: $29.95
    Chaos Men screenshot
    Chaos Men
    Date: 2018-05-05
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Chaos Men might sound like an odd name, but these lusty, manly gay amateurs are going to knock your socks off. The content quality is excellent, they have a great site setup, and the collection is gigantic. There's no reason not to join this site.

  • Now: $24.95
    Amateur Canadian Guys screenshot
    Amateur Canadian Guys
    Date: 2010-04-20
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: Amateur Canadian Guys takes you into the world of this pansexual Canadian nightclub, and you are going to love every minute of it. There's nothing quite like seeing these guys getting into their performances, and there's something for everyone in this massive collection. The quality isn't the best, but you aren't going to mind that once they get their dicks swinging.

  • Now: $19.95
    Vintage Gay Male screenshot
    Vintage Gay Male
    Date: 2010-03-26
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: Feeling nostalgic? Then maybe you're in the mood for some vintage gay porn - and Vintage Gay Male does an excellent job at making sure that you get exactly what you want. Although it suffers from some organization issues and a few broken links, overall you're going to love the main site, and the Bad Puppy network delivers on any modern porn that you might be craving.

  • Now: $19.95
    SeeMyBF screenshot
    Date: 2009-12-23
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: There are only a few gay amateur sites like See My BF out there, and I don't think any of them come close to the entertainment and collection that this site has. For amateur and self submitted photos and videos the quality is good, and the consistent updates give you plenty to look forward to.

  • Now: $17.99 Was: $29.95
    Czech Hunter screenshot
    Save 40%
    Czech Hunter
    Date: 2019-07-22
    Your price: $17.99. Save 40%

    Summary: Amateur Czech Guys get stopped on the streets, they're asked if they need money and they always do, and then they are asked what they are prepared to do for it. They always end up at least blowing the guy if not letting him fuck them. That's Czech Hunter content right there, and there's plenty of it, in HD and with easy and low-cost access. If you want Euro reality and straight to gay, gay for pay POV, then this is the site for you.

  • Now: $29.95
    Alternadudes screenshot
    Date: 2018-05-05
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: If you want to know where all the really interesting men are in gay porn, you'll find them at Alterna Dudes. These guys come from all over, the goths, the emos, the skaters, the punks, the surfers, and while you won't see them very often on mainstream gay porn sites, they're kicking ass and taking names in this HD porn extravaganza.

  • Now: $19.95
    Jason Strong Tickling screenshot
    Jason Strong Tickling
    Date: 2010-12-16
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: Jason Strong is a sexy guy through and through and his love of gay tickle fetish makes him that much more delicious. Jason has a good sized and growing collection of exclusive tickle fetish and a lot of personality that makes this site a real winner.

  • Now: $24.95
    College Dudes screenshot
    College Dudes
    Date: 2010-10-18
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: College Boys doesn't feature dorm room cams or anything like that instead it's a college amateur site that features 18-21 year olds getting themselves into plenty of solo and hardcore action. The collection is large with frequent updates, and while it doesn't make a great first impression it ends up being solid overall.

  • Now: $10.95
    Drake Cameron screenshot
    Drake Cameron
    Date: 2010-10-11
    Your price: $10.95.

    Summary: Put two photographers together, named Drake and Cameron, let them loose to find the hottest amateur men around, and then have them film their explorations in HD. What you get is a great gay porn site that focuses on quality over quantity, but gives you a bit enough collection that you're not going to be bored anytime soon.

  • Now: $14.95 Was: $29.95
    Cody Cummings screenshot
    Save 51%
    Cody Cummings
    Date: 2016-09-02
    Your price: $14.95. Save 51%

    Summary: Cody Cummings is a hunky, muscular bisexual guy that tends to walk on the man side way more than the times he hooks up with girls. There's just something about cock he can't deny. This HD solo gay pornstar site features a lot of action, and a lot of content. There's a few bumps in the road, but overall it's a very solid experience.

  • Now: $29.95
    Next Door Pass screenshot
    Next Door Pass
    Date: 2010-10-05
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Take 8 of the hottest exclusive amateur gay sites out there, and offer them for one price. If you think that sounds like a winner, you're looking at a site that did just that. Next Door Pass features all of the Next Door Studio offerings, and you'll get to enjoy each and every one of these sites. The network setup itself is a bit odd, but it won't detract too much from your browsing experience.

  • Now: $17.99 Was: $24.95
    Sean Cody screenshot
    Save 28%
    Sean Cody
    Date: 2019-06-10
    Your price: $17.99. Save 28%

    Summary: Amateur porn doesn't have to be about grainy videos shot in hotel rooms where the camera tips and all you see is a pair of legs. You can get pro-quality porn from sites like Sean Cody where the cast are amateurs, but where the crew are not. This combo gives you hot videos, first-time porn boys, some more experienced and top-quality results. Check out or recent review and take a look; it's got over 2,556 videos to get you going.

  • Now: $17.99 Was: $29.99
    Reality Dudes screenshot
    Save 41%
    Reality Dudes
    Date: 2018-07-31
    Your price: $17.99. Save 41%

    Summary: Amateur gay porn used to be a case of hiring someone who didn't mind being filmed fucking and then bunging up a video on your site. These days it's much more of an art and many sites pretend to film amateurs, but the movies you get are cleverly worked out and staged pro-movies made to look amateur. Meh. I like the read deal and at Reality Dudes, you find it. This seven-site offer in one network, gives you, among others, Dick Dorm where a guy holds a cam and tells his straight and gay mates what to do. They haze and party, drink and hang out and then they get sexy, intimae, into each other's asses and covered in cum. It's perfect reality porn and, via Reality Dudes, you can find its 107 movies, plus over 800 others in your bonus sites.

  • Now: $39.95
    Eric Deman screenshot
    Eric Deman
    Date: 2018-05-05
    Your price: $39.95.

    Summary: Any sort of gay porn or straight guy sneak peeks you can think of are shown at Eric Deman, but they take a particular delight in showing off athletes and celebrities in compromising and just damn sexy positions. The navigation and layout is a bit of a mess, but you are going to forget that once you see the size of this collection.

  • Now: $19.95
    Big Gay Apple screenshot
    Big Gay Apple
    Date: 2010-03-23
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: Big Gay Apple won't get you interested when you look at the very sparse tour, but you'd be disappointed if you pass this one up. The personality of the site and the variety of features helps to offset a severe lack on the technical side of things, and you'll find yourself loving the bonus network as well.

  • Now: $29.95
    Defiant Boyz screenshot
    Defiant Boyz
    Date: 2009-10-27
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Defiant Boyz is all about skaters and other amateur guys that you'll see right next door, getting as nasty as you could want. This site is run by Defiant Productions, who has been at it in the amateur gay porn scene for 10 years and now they bring everything online. The collection is massive with a great update schedule, and the only real downfall is the fact that they need more browsing options.

  • Now: $24.95
    Boys First Time screenshot
    Boys First Time
    Date: 2009-10-14
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: When these guys decide to have their first gay experience, they don't want to do it behind closed doors. They want the world to know what they're doing, so they go ahead and go for it on camera. That's the best idea ever, and Boys First Time captures over 300 of these experiences. With a big collection, a long running site, and frequent updates this one is a real winner.

  • Now: $34.95
    Club Amateur USA screenshot
    Club Amateur USA
    Date: 2017-03-15
    Your price: $34.95.

    Summary: Club Amateur USA is more than just amateurs - it features straight guys curious enough to explore their gay sides. This is a large site on the Bad Puppy network, and it has a good collection of videos, gorgeous amateurs, and a great network to back it all up.

  • Now: $29.95
    His First Huge Cock screenshot
    His First Huge Cock
    Date: 2018-05-05
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: His First Big Cock takes you on an adventure with plenty of massive dongs going right for these asses. The collection is available primarily in HD, with older episodes getting converted over. Along with the large collection, you get bonus access to Male Spectrum Pass for even more gay hardcore action.

  • Now: $29.95
    Male Spectrum Pass screenshot
    Male Spectrum Pass
    Date: 2011-03-14
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Male Spectrum Pass is a gay hardcore megasite that has a good thousand episodes featuring all sorts of sexy amateurs and pornstars who are in the mood for a reaming. This megasite has a good sized collection and bonuses, but it does suffer when it comes to an easy to use layout for getting around the massive collection.

  • Now: $19.95
    M2M Club screenshot
    M2M Club
    Date: 2011-01-11
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: M2M Club is an amateur gay porn site that delivers plenty of content variety for a good price. You'll see pretty much every amateur gay porn niche around, but this collection is hampered a bit by a clunky interface and relatively low quality videos.

  • Squirtz screenshot
    Date: 2010-10-08

    Summary: Squirtz features amateur Canadian men who love showing off their dick or sucking one too. All of the men filmed are from Montreal, and the size of the collection has me impressed that there are that many amateurs from the area just waiting to be filmed. The video quality is good amateur, and while the site doesn't have a ton of features it does have the most important feature regular updates.

  • Now: $24.95
    Gear Action screenshot
    Gear Action
    Date: 2010-10-01
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: Gear Action shows off guys in the uniforms of your dreams, and you're going to have your dick out before you realize what's going on. Athletic uniforms are the most prevelant, so if you're had a dream of fucking your favorite footballer you know this is going to do it for you. A good sized collection and decent quality content will keep you happy, as well as the weekly updates.

  • Now: $29.95
    Out in Public screenshot
    Out in Public
    Date: 2010-10-01
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Out in Public features two guys that work to seduce as many men as possible and take them right in the street. There are some guys that go for restaurant head, and others that want to get down and dirty in the alleyways. No matter where they go, they are sure to be seen by someone. This is a small site as of yet, but weekly updates grow this unique collection quickly. It is streaming only, but the Flash is very high quality and also available as clips for slower connections.

  • Now: $29.95
    Gay College Sex Parties screenshot
    Gay College Sex Parties
    Date: 2011-04-01
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Gay College Sex Parties is the wildest ride through higher education that you've ever seen. These naughty gay amateurs enjoy the parties every chance that they get, making sure they're sampling a wide variety of dick. The HD videos look good, but the update schedule is remarkably slow as of late.

  • Now: $19.95
    Hard Working Stiff screenshot
    Hard Working Stiff
    Date: 2010-03-29
    Your price: $19.95.

    Summary: Hard Working Stiff is one of those sites that might not offer all of the bells and whistles that you come to expect out of modern pornsites, but it does present a good experience with niches that are rather rare to find - Canadians and blue collar men. They just need a quality increase to really help them stand out in the crowd.

  • Now: $29.95
    Spunk Starz screenshot
    Spunk Starz
    Date: 2009-10-30
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Spunk Starz features cute first time on film gay amateurs sharing their most intimate of moments. The collection is a decent size, the updates come fast and furious as the guys, and the video quality is above average. If you're in the mood for some great first time action, stop through here.

  • Now: $29.95
    Jeremy Roddick screenshot
    Jeremy Roddick
    Date: 2010-10-11
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Jeremy Roddick features a sexy stud that has a sex drive that is never ending. He fucks all sorts of guys that come across his doorstep, and his exploits are featured in good quality videos. There is no sort of personal interaction you would expect from a solo model site, but you do get two extra bonus sites.

  • Now: $24.95
    Dick Show screenshot
    Dick Show
    Date: 2010-09-20
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: Dick Show features yummy amateurs whipping out their dicks and having a good old time with themselves. While they work themselves into an explosive orgasm, you'll see that the video quality is on the low side, and it's a very sparse and bare bones site.

  • Now: $24.95
    Papi screenshot
    Date: 2009-10-12
    Your price: $24.95.

    Summary: If you love party boys showing off their tight bodies and pounding away with those big dicks, Papi is going to cast a spell over you from the first time that you see it. The video quality is good, and the collection of exclusive reality gay Latino porn is solid as well. However it suffers from a lack of updates, and that dampens my attraction to it.

  • Now: $14.95
    Bareback Beginners screenshot
    Bareback Beginners
    Date: 2009-08-25
    Your price: $14.95.

    Summary: Bareback Beginners makes a lot of promises but really doesn't keep any of them. There are no HD videos or updates, and the collection is smaller than the amount of random guys willing to fuck without a condom. Unless you're in for the bonus network, you'll want to get your fix somewhere else.

  • Now: $29.95
    Gay Blind Date Sex screenshot
    Gay Blind Date Sex
    Date: 2009-07-28
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Gay Blind Date Sex under delivers in every aspect, from video quality to misleading tour claims. If you're looking to get into the bonus network you should stop by, but if you're just after the content from this site, you should look elsewhere.

  • Now: $29.95
    Self Shot Boys screenshot
    Self Shot Boys
    Date: 2011-03-23
    Your price: $29.95.

    Summary: Self Shot Boys features gay amateur guys taking pictures and videos of themselves in some very naughty situations, but it promises way more than it delivers. The collection is tiny, the photo galleries are huge sets that don't really look homemade, and it's a streaming only site.

← Previous Page Next Page →
Total 34 reviews