Your guide to better porn!

HomeCategoriesStraightDirty Tony review

Dirty Tony review

Summary: Dirty Tony is the type of site that you just love to hang out at it has a very great content base, a site owner that shows that he cares about every little detail by giving you great videos and a decent set of options to check them out with, and the variety of amateurs will keep you popping back in for the frequent updates.

Score 90.0 /100
About Our Ratings
Tiffany, 2010-07-26

Straight, Amateur, Hardcore, Hunks-and-Muscle

hot amateur hunks, real gay amateurs, sexy gay amateurs

Intro promises

Straight guys corrupted
Bonus sites
Free webcam

First impression

Dirty Tony just loves to through themselves right in the middle of debauchery, especially when it occurs between a (semi) straight guy and a hunky gay guy. Most of the guys are amateurs through and through, in their mid 20s at most, and definitely don't mind that the camera is on once they see each other.

The member's area follows the theme of the tour, and you get an amateur looking but well designed member's area. Most of your bonuses are in the top navigation, while you can choose the categories along the sidebar. The categories are split by scene action, physical attributes, sexual orientation, and age. You can also go month by month through the archives. Finally the episode listings go down the middle of the page.


Payment Processors:

Our opinion

Dirty Tony's site setup almost reminds me of a blog for whatever reason it just gives me that distinct impression. You get updates about once every 4 to 5 days, and it looks like Tony is one active fucker that loves getting all sorts of male attention. Of course there are plenty of other men as well, with a great variety of amateurs that encompass many different body types, mostly jocks and twinks. There are 297 episodes in total.

The video pages give you a slick Silverlight player with plenty of options, and underneath you get information about the models, the scene, and their statistics. There is also a full scene download in MP4 (although it starts off zipped). Finally there's a photo gallery hanging out at the bottom of the page. There are tags to allow for more precise searching for similar scenes. You can pick four different qualities with the player window, as well as being able to pick from screenshots where you go in the scene. Buffering time is very quick, and while the video player stays the same at the 640x360, you'll see the differences in bitrate from version to version. The highest quality looks to be around 3 mbps, then it goes down through 2 mbps, 1 mbps, and 500 kbps. The MP4 is 1280x720 and 4 mbps, a HD porn experience that I wasn't entirely expecting to get to check out at an amateur site. Older downloads are given in MOV format, and shown at 480x360 and 1 mbps.

While you might look at Dirty Tony's site and think that it's just the same as countless other amateur gay porn sites, there's just something special with his men that makes it stand out in the crowd. It has more to do with the great technical quality - these guys have real sexual chemistry, as well as that eagerness to get naughty in front of the camera. It's just the kind of mischievous feel that you would expect from sexy amateur guys.

The photo sets have around 60 pictures per set on average, and they are good amateur quality at 531x800. They're a bit on the small side, but the composition is very good and there are quite a few shots that would make their way into your permanent collection. They follow along with the scenes, although they are not screencaps in the least. There are zip downloads for each set.

Bonuses are given along the top the first webcam link is just an upsell, but there's a cam feed of college guys that you get access to, a blog that covers various aspects of their site and the gay porn world, a studio cam that shows the studio, but does not seem to have a schedule as of yet. There are also 8 third party feeds with various gay hardcore porn.


I really enjoyed the variety of amateur men that paraded their way through Dirty Tony's site. The camera work is excellent, especially when it comes to the videos, and the variety is particularly nice. You'll get all sorts of delicious guys here, and there is no holds barred when it comes to the fucking. You'll want to take a look here for sure if you're even the least bit interested.


Screenshot 1 from members areaScreenshot 2 from members areaScreenshot 3 from members areaScreenshot 4 from members areaScreenshot 5 from members area


Image sample 1 from members areaImage sample 2 from members areaImage sample 3 from members areaImage sample 4 from members areaImage sample 5 from members area

External Opinions

Don't take our word for it and see what others think! We have collected a list of opinions and impressions from other sites, so you can compare them all from one place.

Total average: 80.5/100 Our score: 90.0/100

User Comments

Write your comment - feedback is appreciated


Comments from other readers

2012-01-23 04:20:03

Could give it 5 stars BUT...

I ended up at dirtytony because of one thing, the bukkake videos. I love seeing a group of guys cum all over a sub guy's face after they each take turns getting sucked by him. All seemed perfect UNTIL the ending when out of nowhere a female voice says to the naked guys, one of who's face is still oozing cum, "happy birthday to you." or some crap. Talk about a huge buzzkill! I did not need to know there was a woman on the set watching, or worse possibly running the camera crew!? This happens at the end of at least two of the bukkakes, Trey Thornton's and Trent Atkins' scenes. Thanks for ruining an otherwise hot masturbation experience for me. If we can't expect to get away from female interference even in ALL-MALE porn then that truly sucks! I won't be paying membership to this site.